Teachers and Health Care
March 5th, 2011It continues to amaze me that our elected government officials think they are the best decision makers about everything. I think they’ve forgotten that they are to represent us, not govern us. A democracy is about people being able to govern themselves. I will admit that not everyone is capable of that, but I believe that the majority of us are.
Do we need to re-vamp the Health Care system in America? Of course we do. No one argues with that. What we disagree on is who should re-vamp it and what it should look like once it’s re-vamped. However, the last people who should be doing it are our elected officials. What do they know about health care, insurance, medical problems, and prescription drugs? Wouldn’t it make more sense to assemble a large, organized and focused group of doctors, nurses, insurance adjusters, insurance providers, and lay people from each of the various economic levels in our country?
Those assembled would first determine what the “Larger Commitment” was that they were working on. What did they want, bottom line, for every American? Believe it or not, we all have an idea of what that should be. And most of us, Republican, Democrat, Independent, or Other, want the same thing. Our similarities will always outweigh our differences if we take the time to notice.
Once the “Larger Commitment” is established, similar, smaller groups could meet together so that each participating representative might express their insight, concerns, and suggestions for each of the areas of health care. Then each group would bring the best of their brainstorming together to share with the larger group. This may take a little longer than some want it to take, and it may be stressful within the groups as people work towards a common goal, but it could and should be done. Then the bill should be put to the legislators to share with their constituents and find out if there is agreement among the majority of those they serve. I could almost guarantee that following this, America would have the best health care system in the world. Basic health care and wellness care would be available for all. Extended services and additional options might only be available to those with employee benefits or those with more money, but like it or not, we do live in a free market society and people have what they can afford. As Americans, we would be happier and more content if we quit complaining about the wealthy (FYI: I personally do not fit in that bracket) and begrudging them their wealth, and simply enjoyed what we do have, accepting this as “being fair.”
The second area in which elected officials make decisions about things they know little about is education. I think they feel that since they went to school they are qualified to determine how the education system should function. That is like the Holiday Inn Express commercial in which the guest feels qualified to be a brain surgeon simply because he stayed at the hotel.
In Florida, the Legislature passed a bill requiring all seniors to successfully pass Algebra 2 and the accompanying End Of Course exam in order to graduate. Why? One representative suggested that if they had the thinking skills to pass Algebra 2, they could then be successful in life. Really?
I’m just a Middle School / High School math teacher, but I think the Florida Legislature just wanted to look good to the rest of the country. If they were really committed to having graduating seniors prepared to be successful in life, if they truly cared about helping them create a future to live in to, Algebra 2 would not even be on the table. What every graduating senior in America needs, in my humble opinion, is an extensive course in Financial Literacy. In this course, which is not yet developed they way it needs to be, the student would learn about the stock market, invest in a mock stock market throughout the school year, and have the opportunity to actually invest in the real stock market if they chose to. They would learn how to buy a house, determine repairs needed before moving in, and figure the cost of those repairs. They would learn about buying a car and have to work through the pressure of the sales pitch. Students would have mock bank accounts and have to earn money, determined by their grades on their work. They would have bills to pay and penalties for late payments. AND, before the end of their senior year, each student would have a retirement plan in place and begin making contributions. With the forecast of a depleted Social Security fund, what better way to prepare our students for the future than to prepare them to be responsible for, and invest in, their own future.
If elected officals could only but remember that they serve in a government office they aren’t the government. We, the people are the government. Elected officals are our servants. They represent our needs, our desires, and our collective perspective. If education needs reform, and most teachers agree that it does, get massive input from real teachers, most of whom already share a “Larger Committment,” not just someone who went to school. And if you really want to reform health care, you should ask those who work in the healthcare network.